I think Serenity mentioned this somewhere already:
http://www.webhostingtalk.com/We are not a professional hosting forum, with our handful of hosting users it could easily mislead those that are basing their decision on what is said here only. For any hosting company look up I would go to WHT. There have a lot more hosting users and would give a better picture of which company should be trusted.
For the paid service section, it would be impossible to guarantee the service is good before letting them advertise it. I mean I remember those two hostings that were recently removed from the section used to be good and respectable until they turned bad. I could only suggest the usual saying "buyer be aware" and watch out for complain posts made in the thread.
Here is a part of a pm I got from BMar after locking his thread and questioning his practice:
Hi yC,
Taken from the RateMyServer Paid Guidelines:
TO ALL USERS:
All services listed here, for both recruiting and employing party, are "USE AT YOUR OWN RISK". Ratemyserver.net forum has no obligation to monitor the quality delivered and would not take responsibility for any loss or damage incurred.
Could I ask how is posting in my topic about how I run my services and locking my thread, "not monitoring the quality delivered and taking responsibility"?
Service providers or anyone shouldn't assume that RMS don't care what is posted in the paid section obviously. We have the right to and we will step in whenever we see something is fishie going on.
Although I admit with the case of this BMar it was too late and it damaged some servers. Even upon asking him to give reasonable refunds and open up his server so his customers can get backups he went totally idiotic and said "Just wondering, why do you care?" + "Were you a client of mine?". Now this is terrible, this company owner used to be nice and helpful in his thread. He suddenly changed his face and decided to scam everyone then run away.
I could only explain that could be because the cut throat price war on RO hostings are driving these companies to lose money. So he might as well turn it into a scam to make a profit while he can. So what I wanna say? Oh yea .. it's hard for anyone to tell the good apple from the bad ones if it is well hidden. Unfortunately survey, free-trial or review can only do so much.