Bit of a topic Redemptio considering I've never spoken up about tRO before, though a warning -
this will be a long post.Bit of personal background to understand where I'm coming from: I have been with Talon since it's birth, back to even the days when it was still Anima, so I guess I'm classified as a Veteran. I've played on several other servers since TalonRO began to present day for periods of time ranging from 3 weeks to 4 months, including 1/1/1's, highly populated mid-rates and servers with what was considered to provide 'non-game-breaking' donation items. And yet, after all that, I still return to Talon.. Read on.
Server Stability & AvailabilityVery stable. There have been a few instances I can recall where I've suddenly experienced hardcore lag spikes, but it usually always turned out to be my internet, my location or the server host. Downtime usually lasts anywhere between 15 minutes for a reboot to an hour and a half for updates. Every now and again, I error out or crash suddenly only to realise I needed to update my Sakray or patch up - which says a lot on the update-rate of the server.
tl;dr - Stable.
Community Friendliness and EventfulnessTalon's community is very tight knit - probably because of the fact that it's at a small player base at the moment and the length of server-life. Although everyone knows each other (generally

), that doesn't mean that the tRO community are snobs and fail to welcome newbie players - both new to RO as a whole and new to Talon from another server. I've heard of many uplifting stories about a newer player retelling a story about how one person donated a few hundred meats or grape juice for levelling, buffing at will, tanking, easy conversation and over all receiving advice and directions of where particular custom features are. As with every server, there will be tension, and sure Talon has it's handful of flame wars and 'KoS-ing' and, thankfully, these usually die down with apologies or truces. Hate doesn't last long here

. Events are plentiful on the server. Seiren and Shiris are both active event facilitators and it keeps us all amused. I always feel like a child in preschool constantly being kept entertained

. Examples of events is the perennial Forum events of search and screenie, Shiris' LH Survivor event, TalonRO World Cup and even player-run events such as The Reaper's Game, and not to mention events in the past such as the Halloween Coin Event and the Christmas Toy Factory Quiz. Quests keep an individual entertained for hours too - not only eA's usual quests but tRO's Super Quest Item series and the recently introduced Hat Dyeing quests.
tl;dr - Friendly, mature community, helpful, ever-ready to help. Lots of events.
Game Master Availability, Friendliness and Helpfulness.Good grief, where do I start? Talon GMs have to be the most awesome, most creative (Faith), most knowledgeable (Shiris), most hard working (Boreas), and most player-friendly (Seiren) I have
ever experienced. I'm not sure what to say about Black Talon though... he has his active spurts and then his incognito periods of time, but I'm empathetic because I know how time consuming real life committments can be. There have been bumps in availability because of RL commitments, but the slack is usually picked up by the other members of the team. There is almost always a GM present, even in my deserted timezone (I live in Australia), most notably Seiren, who seems like he doesn't sleep just to keep the forums clean and user friendly. They are incredibly helpful - and this goes hand in hand with their individual experience of long years playing RO. I notice that they don't speak unless they are certain of their information which is always accurate and they outsource material for guides too. One thing that I know a few players have been having a problem with lately is the few unanswered Support Tickets which require a High GM's attention, mainly for the inclusion of non-existing customized Kahos which require server reboots. They are all very friendly... I think it's the Talon GMs that are the glue to the community being so tight.
tl;dr - The best.
Economy, Guild Competition and Class BalanceThe economy has improved a lot considering what it used to be. MVP cards range from 9 million to (approx) 25 million zeny depending on the card in question. I know some people have gripes that 25million is a lot of money for a newbie to raise single handedly on Talon, and all I can say to that is if you don't put in the hard yards, you won't reap the benefits - and it's not like you won't receive help. Also, it was mentioned earlier by someone where they said that with all the MVP cards on TalonRO, that even though they're obtainable through zeny, that SOMEone donated for them at one point in time. I think with that, people are forgetting that Talon was once a part of AnimaRO. If you consider the fact that a large quantity of the existing MVP cards on the server existed even before Talon officially began, that lessens the magnitude of what people think of the amount of donations that have truly been put into Talon. Guild competition at the moment is not as great as it could be. With most of the top tier guilds opting out of WoE because of inactivity, it's mostly Non Trans and small Trans guilds that really participate during WoE. Talon has 3 weekly Wars of Emperium - 2 'normal' old school style WoE's with a limited number of castles and WoE 2.0. My only concern with WoE's in this style is 2.0 where the gameplay of 2.0 and it's mechanic really require a population that Talon currently do not have. Concerning Class Balance, I think it is level. People complain about GTB in PvP against Wizards, but I've witnessed
plenty of innovative HW's who have easily bypassed that. As a side note, Talon has a thriving Champion population - probably because Champ duels in PvP are quite fun and competitive. Custom SQI items and Custom MVP cards to TalonRO are in the process of being under review by the GMs in an attempt to further balance the classes, so I can damn well say for sure that it's heading in the right direction.
tl;dr - Economy is generally fair. Guild competition could do with a boost. Class balance is fair at the moment, and Cards/Gears are up for review.
Other Notes:
PvPPvP is very competitive in Talon. It's amazing to think how many skilled, innovative and determined players tRO has when it comes to PvP. As previously stated, there is a healthy Champ population, but that doesn't mean Talon's dry in classes elsewhere. If you live in the Americas or Europe, you'll most probably find that PvP is always abuzz with action. If you live on an Island like me (Australiaaa!), it's quiet at the times you'd usually get on to play. Players
do KoS in PvP and I don't think much can be done about that - unless it evolves to personal harassment, and at that point, GMs intervene

. A lot of players treat PvP as a 'meet up' zone. I usually see most of my friends in PvP, and we talk and socialise, violently poke, and heal up, kill, 'misclick-kill' (haha) and have fun and banter in Public PvP. Talon also has a Non Trans only PvP for players who are not so well geared. I'd have to say that the tRO 'veterans' have adjusted well to the change from Aegis to eAthena PvP - it's all so exciting now.
PopulationThe server player count states that there's around 250 or so players on at a time. I admit that around 100-120 of those logged in are autovenders, but a small population certainly has its charms... like an un-laggy Prontera, clean streets with no street venders, easy not to feel so overwhelmed, easy to find vends, not all your MVPs are camped religiously and it's certainly a little more personal than say a server with 1000+ players.
DonationsSomeone also mentioned earlier in this thread about the pricing of donation items available in TalonRO. Yeah, $100 for LKH is steep and pricey... but the last time I have ever heard anyone actually donate for LKH's was probably... a year ago? Around about there. For the past few months, the only donations that I see people paying for are Name Changes, Sex Changes, Kaho Customization and the sort. MVP cards... Rarely hear about anyone donating for MVP cards since the free server-wide unslot many months ago. All in all, I think the donations are pretty much set, though that's my personal point of view

.
Talon Main Site & ForumsThe Talon front page was recently revamped thanks to GM Seiren and GM Faith. How sexy is it?! It's easy to navigate, everything is easy on the eyes and it doesn't have six million 'reasons why you should vote for us!!11oneeleven' signs. It's sleek and professional

. The TalonRO forums are generally quite active. I guess a lot of players are just social butterflies. Lots of banter and play happen on the forums as well as strategic discussions. The players are always kept informed via the Forums, so it's best that if you join, you register and say hello

. A few things bother me personally though concerning the forums - namely the sea of porn bots and the rare occasion there's a lack of decency shown by players towards other players. Our neighbourhood forum moderator Seiren always reigns those porn bots in and tactfully mediates the threads. All in all, it's a very enjoyable place to socialise.
In conclusion...Talon's a great server. Best I've personally ever seen. It'll be the last server I'll ever play on, and I stated in my review that I'm sticking with Talon till it dies. There's something about this server that just tickles my loyalty buds.
I hope my review wasn't extremely biased.. I tried to be objective on all counts. And I also hope that this helps someone else in their search for more (err.. more-more) information concerning TalonRO.
Ephemeral - aka
Anixiel.