in case of a PvP situation, i think d damage given back 2 d enemy is always consistent of its attack damage done 2 u(e.g. just for example! let's say a knight did 1000 damage to you and let's say dat reflect shield can reflect damage done by d enemy on u by 50%, it should exactly reflect 500 damage 2 d enemy!)! as 4 d orc lady, i seem t b clueless---i'm sorry...